There's a waxed paper gasket and rubber o ring. Both go on dry. Careful not to overtighten the cover bolts.

If you remove the old and it looks clean, just test it out in a pot of water with an instant read thermometer and put it back in if it is opening as expected.

If it falls apart in your hands like mine did, replace it.

Sent from my OnePlus 5 using Tapatalk