Go Surf Assist / WaveControl system on '07 LSV: Love it but not recommended
Summary: I installed the WaveControl system (same as Go Surf Assist but bought from WakeMakers) and installed it on our ’07 LSV. We love it, but BE WARNED: GSA told me that their kit cannot be used on this hull. I would not recommend it to anyone with this same hull unless you are very handy, and savvy both mechanically and with micro-controllers, PCB soldering, etc.
Full Story:I installed the tabs following the instructions as best as I could, took it for the first test and found that it was completely unusable. It couldn't make a wave in any setting. I contacted Go Surf and got in touch with a very friendly and helpful tech support guy (Ryan?). After talking to him for a bit he asked about the boat and said something like "oh that Mobius transom is ugly, basically we tell folks it won't work on that boat and won't sell the system". Crap. I just wasted a lot of money and drilled 16 holes in my boat (including 2 rather large ones for the cables)
There are 2 problems with the installation and instructions.
1. The transom is not "flat" like virtually every other boat. It has those sculpted little ridges which mess up the installation template and the operating geometry.
2. The instructions (at least from Wakemakers at the time) basically said something like select the actuator connection point such that the deployed angle is at least 18 degrees (or 11?). When I talked to Go Surf, he said "oh no, the deploy angle should be 0-5 degrees.
So here's what I did: I threw away the installation instructions and template. They were way over-simplified anyway which would probably be fine 90% of the time. I removed the actuator mounting and epoxied all the holes (I now have white scars on the transom as proof of my pains). I manually located the actuator mounts so that 1) the tabs were nearly touching the swim platform when retracted and 2) they were aligned such that operating geometry was aligned without binding throughout the full deploy/retract travel of the actuator. This was not easy but it can be done with lots of time, experimentation, patience and a meticulous attention to detail, millimeters matter.
The next problem was that to achieve an installation with a functional geometry, the tabs had way too much travel. Basically the controller goes full out and then you can make little "adjustments" but I needed the tabs to only deploy part-way. I tried to get in touch with the guy at GSA that wrote the controller firmware to see about a modification (David?). After a dozen, un-returned calls and way too many weeks trying I gave up, took matters into my own hands and wrote new firmware myself. I made the motor deployment timer a variable and added some serial interface commands to adjust it in real time. After experimenting for many, many hours, I had some reasonably good code and some set points that were giving me a deployed angle of 0 degrees.
And now... it's SWEEEEET! We're making a nice big, clean wave with just a push of a button. I love being able to easily switch sides and ride every combination of regular/goofy, heelside/toeside. I can even hop the wave and transition while riding now. The only downside as far as I'm concerned is that we run with more ballast (both 1100# ballast bags nearly full) and the fuel economy has suffered as a result. I think we're burning more than 6 gal/hour when slammed. I usually fill ballast to 75% to save a bit of fuel as the impact to the wave is noticeable but not significant.
The controller is just an Arduino with standard peripherals for the motor control, remote control and GPS. ($50 of common parts). The control panel has very nice fit and finish, A+ here. None of the PCBs are conformal-coated or otherwise sealed/protected for a “marine” application. The actual tabs are well made and clearly took some R&D investment. I wanted to build my own system as the price seems way too high for the product but my wife didn’t want me to start another R&D project of my own so we decided that the price was worth my time. Unfortunately, I ended up spending quite a bit of time on this, so I can no longer justify the price, but by that time I was already committed.
There are some things in my firmware that are not final. I haven’t implemented anything with GPS for speed protection like the GSA system does, nor the “launch” feature which allows you to use it as a regular trim tab. I am happy to share what I’ve written but only very cautiously as this is way beyond a simple installation and I’m in no position to get into the support world.
The attachements here don't seem to work so I'll add pictures later if I can get it working.
Go Surf Assist / WaveControl system on '07 LSV: Love it but not recommended
I get the impression that you are much more precise in your work than I am. [emoji1688][emoji1787]
I have installed 2 GSA systems on two boats, but nothing even remotely as complicated as you are describing. I think the hard one took me 4 hours.
Thanks for your feedback. I need to eyeball this boat quick!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk