I will be picking one in next couple of days. What do you have?
What's best bang for the buck?
What do you love or hate about yours?
Not that I have a baller budget but if I did what would you suggest?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Printable View
I will be picking one in next couple of days. What do you have?
What's best bang for the buck?
What do you love or hate about yours?
Not that I have a baller budget but if I did what would you suggest?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Hate the Airdog it takes forever to get GPS, when it does it wont pass the pre-flight checks by the time this is sorted theres less than 10 minutes flying time and you cant land it on a boat.
Love Mavic Pro
DJI Mavic. Close thread.
Not sure what your budget is though.
It isn't on the cheap side at about $1,000 with everything but it is highly portable, takes very good stabilized shots, follow mode, 4k video, practically flies itself, auto landing, 20+ minute flight time. highly programmable and a blast to fly. It has a ton of other features as well.
At around $500 you have the DJI Spark as well.
Stay away from the Go Pro Karma. It has had many many problems.
Thanks for tip on go pro. They seem to be in every store here.
Would the spark keep up with boat at 22mph?
Dji phantom looks to be in the middle with features and cost. Thoughts?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Phantom 4 is a great drone. It has a better camera than the Mavic and it a good proven design. It is not highly portable but it is a great choice and you would get great results.
Trayson has a Spark and has been using it quite a bit. It goes about 30 MPH and a flight time of about 15 minutes. Personally I would get the fly more combo which is $700. The important thing there is that it includes a remote rather than flying with Wi-Fi. You will be flying in close range but Wi-Fi from your phone only goes so far. That is how they keep the price so low though. I think there is less chance of interference with the remote than Wi-Fi. The stronger signal is also harder to be interfered with. Maybe that's just me.
We've been out on the boat with the DJI Phantom 4 a few times, and the Spark a few times. And I know enough about the Mavic to comment on it even though we haven't had it out on the boat yet.
The P4 is a solid performer. It's fast, has lots of battery life and I'd imagine they're selling them for pretty cheap now. The P4 is fast and takes amazing video. We've used it surfing, slalom skiing @ 30 and Wakeboarding at 21.5.
The Mavic is badass. pretty damn portable and has upgraded tech and just an all around winner. Decent battery life, plenty fast. If you can afford it, it's really a great choice because there's not a ton of drawbacks beyond price (around $1200 to $1300 for the flymore package).
I own the DJI Spark. We've used it surfing, but haven't tried it wakeboarding. It's noticeably slower than the mavic. It is spec'd at a 16 minute battery life, but don't plan on getting more than like 12. It's TINY. Like you have to see it to appreciate it tiny. I really like how everything fits in a small carry bag. (the bag is like 8x6x3.5" it's super compact and I fit the spark, 2 batteries, a 12v charger, a couple cables, the RC controller and the spark itself into the bag easily).
The spark actually has a 4k sensor but outputs video in only up to 1080p for image stabilization. That said, the video that comes from the spark is badass. I got my spark in August with the flymore package for $680 shipped on Amazon, though I saw a sale recently for $600. They sell the barebones spark for around $500, but you don't get the remote control and have to fly it via wifi on your phone. NO THANKS!
The spark has some fun "quickshot" modes where you can highlight a subject and have it do a pan away, circle, helix, or rocket shot of the subject. Great for a little 10 second FB or IG video.
Bottom line, the spark is for someone like me that's not too serious, and wanted to get into a fun drone for the lower end of the budget. it has extreme portability, but certainly some compromises on speed and battery life. Sure, I wouldn't mind the mavic, but I just didn't have that kind of budget. The P4 would be fine I guess from a utilitarian standpoint if you want the flight performance and don't care much about portability and could get a good deal on one. but if the prices are at all similar, I'd take the mavic all day, every day for it's size/portability. The P4 basically needs it's own backpack.
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-Y_qNwfFHP...ark%2Bsize.jpg
Here's a video of my buddy flying the drone for me. It was his first time with the Spark, but he's a really good pilot on the P4 and Mavic.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQcJV5vrO-I
Here's a "quickshot" video from my spark.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BwT6dUN61rQ
Quickshot video from Saturday. DJI Spark
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NejnHjH0hW8
Me taking DJI Spark video the first day I had it at a car event... This is just recording as a flew. Very smooth!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=esOHNIqJAXs
So I asked my buddy that flew my spark for me surfing about the wakeboarding speeds:Quote:
Originally Posted by russellsmojo
His reply was as follows:
It'd probably be fine for one pass, but that'd be it on battery life. I'm still fine with my Spark purchase. As I'd have to have someone good enough as a pilot to fly when I wakeboard anyway. And the only people I know that are good enough pilots have their own drones anyway.Quote:
on a perfect day with no wind, it should do 30. but most people report 20-22mph. I honestly wouldn't do it. That's straight forward too, no turns and such.
That Spark is crazy small next to the Mavic! Looks like it does some good low light. The Mavic just got Quickshot in its last FW upgrade, finally. I end up shooting most of my stuff in 1080P anyway. I don't have an editing machine that can do 4K and it looks good either way.
I really like the quick shots. It's basically a few cool fun shots that those of us that are still learning as pilots would want to do anyway.Quote:
Originally Posted by 5:00
And yeah, it's crazy small and light. To the point where you'd really take it on a day hike or other adventures.
Your friend is probably right about the speed thing in wind Trason. They can all have a bit of trouble in the wind. You can fly pretty comfortably in 15 MPH winds on the Mavic but a head wind will slow it for sure. At that point you have to be in Sport mode which will take it up to about 40 MPH (no wind) which may be needed for wake boarding. It is a pretty quick little machine.
Do these all have follow mode? Can you get it to take off and follow the surfer, without anyone really flying it and the have it land back on the boat?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
One thing I've found (and definitely with the Spark) is that they don't have a dynamic "home" point. so when the drone's done doing it's thing, it wants to return to where it took off from, which is NOT where the boat is anymore. of course you can update your home point, but it doesn't have a way to make home always the location of the moving remote. I might try later the whole follow me thing. haven't done that yet.
As far as "landing", I've never been quite brave enough to try to land on a boat that is typically rocking ever so slightly. and rarely is my rear sun deck ever level because if we're surfing we're listed to a decent degree. Plus the spark doesn't have much for "landing gear". just some little nubs. I've stopped flying with my prop guards to get greater control and efficiency. When I am done with my spark, I bring it in to the back of the boat, get it to hover in front of me, and reach up and grab it by the body and quickly tilt it sideways which immediately kills the engines. So far so good with that approach on about 8 flights over water. Just make sure you don't get too low on battery because you want that reserve capacity if things go wrong...
That is one of two features they JUST added to the Mavic firmware and I wouldn't be surprised if it is on the Spark as well now. This new update will update the home point where the controller is currently and constantly. That is huge when flying from a boat. You can update the home point from the screen manually at any time also but auto is the way to go. I haven't tried it yet.Quote:
Originally Posted by trayson
YES! They do have a follow mode. You can tap on a subject on the screen and it will fill in a green box letting you know you have the subject locked. From there it will lazily follow the subject and you won't get a lot of change of view. It is a hands off flight mode. You can also lock on a subject and fly it as well. That way you get a lock with the camera and you can fly anywhere you want. That is the way to do it if you want a change of scenery.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mgigs7
It works pretty well if you don't try to get the shot in too closely.
Either way make sure you are flying with your hands on the sticks in case something happens.
As far as landing on the boat see what Trayson wrote. I wouldn't recommend it. Even on a good day the boat moves too much. There are plenty of vids of failed attempted landings on moving objects.
That's awesome. I'm gonna go check for firmware updates tonight! HAHA. That said, it's rain and wind all during this week. LAME. so no boating for me.Quote:
Originally Posted by 5:00
I do know that the mavic controller is more advanced than the spark. it has inherent GPS and an LCD screen. so we'll see what I'm actually able to do.
Landing on a boat seemed like it would be easy since they have auto landing features?
Any kind of flotation creation for water just in case?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I am a newbie pilot for sure. but even the "experienced" pilots have never been comfortable trying to land on the boat. they always go in for manual control with someone catching it. I can just see a slight off camber sundeck getting sliced up vinyl from the props.Quote:
Originally Posted by russellsmojo
I've heard some people have made various floats. But everything impacts wind resistance and flight time/control. The DJI care refresh insurance does cover water damage, BUT I'd have to be able to recover the damaged drone. so if it sunk, I'd be sunk. :-(
Hence, risky flying over water. After a successful catch and end of flight session, I breathe a huge sigh of relief! No joke.
I just saw they have the dynamic home point for the Spark now which is awesome. It uses the GPS in your phone or tablet for the GPS update so no problems.
What Trayson said about landing. The problem is that the drone has no information about the boat's dynamics. When the Mavic takes off it gets a photo and video of the launch site which helps. The boat will be moving and add to that wind and it can get tough. It will hover a couple of feet above the target and figure itself out but things are changing along with its GPS position also. I have used auto land on the ground just to do it and I am amazed at how well it does. I have a two foot landing pad and it hits it every time. It uses ultra sound for altitude when landing along with the image matching. If something rises up under it quickly like a boat heaving it may gain altitude again.
There is some amazing technology in these things.
Where can I see the details of these firmware updates? Where are you getting the info?Quote:
Originally Posted by 5:00
Do you think it's worth buying a landing pad for my spark?
It lands on a two foot circle. Wow. And it takes a picture to remember home. No joke. Amazing technology.
What about building a landing pad on our towers? There's a cool winter mod for someone!!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I first saw something about it on a FB forum for the Mavic. For the Spark my app just updated and I saw it there in the changes part. A lot of the same upgrades will probably be available for both. There is also a good forum on the DJI site.Quote:
Originally Posted by trayson
I got the landing pad for taking off in crass and dirt. The image recognition landing really nails it even in moderate wind. If a drone has visual landing assist it is good in grass, keeps dirt down and when you are in something that looks the same it gives it a target. Without it I find cracks or something that looks different than just pavement for example.
I thought about putting a target on the bimini but the higher you are the more the effect of the boat moving. The bigger reason I found for not doing it is safety. Even if you had a flat platform that dron is above everyone's head. If it comes down and the rotors are spinning it could end badly. Most everyone is hand catching them. Really there is no truly safe way to recover on a boat. The Phantom has a nice "grab bar" in the form of its skids. Probably the safest one to hand catch.Quote:
Originally Posted by russellsmojo
Agree completely.Quote:
Originally Posted by 5:00
When I launched in Grass, I just set the carry bag on its side on the ground and used that as my takeoff platform. LOLQuote:
Originally Posted by 5:00
Whatever works. That's the problem with these squatty drones. When they are in the grass the props are cutting grass, the camera gimball is being pushed by the grass, dirt is getting stirred up closer to components. That is what's nice about the Phantom, it sits high above all that crap.Quote:
Originally Posted by trayson
So what did you end up with?Quote:
Originally Posted by russellsmojo
I just picked up a Mavic 2 pro with the flymore kit and water proof pelican case. I was looking at the original mavic for cost purposes but my dad convinced me to go Mavic 2 pro due to the 1" sensor and omni directional avoidance sensors. It also has a slightly more aerodynamic design and long battery life. I got it two days before I had to go back to work so I only got a few flights in with it, none involving the boat. We did take my dads phantom 4 on our boat at canyon lake a few weeks ago and catching it was super easy with two people. I would think on the mavic/mavic 2 you would need to turn off VPS to catch it or else it would see your hand under it and climb. Looking forwards to next summer with.
I upgraded from my spark to a mavic air. I can't say enough good things about the air. It has the 3 axis gimble, a hardwired connection between the controller and the phone (vs Wi-Fi on the spark), faster speed and better battery life. But it's still really small and compact and affordable.
All in the refurbished fly more (with 3 batteries) was $800.
And check out the size with my go pro 7 for reference. In that bag is everything (charging station, 3 batteries, drone, controller, extra cables and props).
As far as landing, I catch mine and quickly turn it sideways to cut the engines.
When I had the spark, there were a few things that I wished were better. The manic air addressed all of them and I am completely happy with no reason to "upgrade" any further. https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...3cf02a95dd.jpghttps://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...3547d4a97b.jpghttps://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...c7ad1c89c7.jpghttps://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...8542bf3bd7.jpg
Sent from my VS995 using Tapatalk
I also recommend DJI Mavic, they are the best drones at the moment. Though they are a bit expensive, it's totally worth it.
How expensive are the DJI Mavic? How much do they cost?
Potensic D58 drone and transmitter were pretty easy to set up and get flying even though this was my first drone purchase. The only trouble I had was with the Potensic-GPS app. It would not load any maps or record video. The good news is I was able to solve both of these problems with a little effort. And you can customize this drone by custom ai drones software
How comfortable do you feel with trying to land on boat?. I still have not taken my air to the lake because of concerns of it dropping over water. Did u purchase any floats?Quote:
Originally Posted by trayson
Id never land on the boat. I always catch mine. Best way to do it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Isaguel
I catch my Mavic Pro as well but it's still unnerving as if it decides to return home it's going for a swim lol.
Also with the collision sensors on the mavic sometimes it tries to run away from you when it senses your hand under it which is also fun on a boat.
This drone looks perfect......
https://youtu.be/07rtBip9ixk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
At 1:06 of that video, is he actually trying to burn the power line?Quote:
Originally Posted by larry_arizona
Looks like it, but maybe showing maneuverability around obstacles?Quote:
Originally Posted by Isaguel
It’s $1499 for the flamethrower attachment and you buy the DJI 600 or DJI 1000 separately.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk