Originally Posted by 
Hayden
				
			 
			In my opinion, this depends; from best case, A) 100 lbs kid on a medium or long board, I would say 8-9deg pitch and 3600-4100 rpm, to worst case, B) +220 lbs man on a small skim board, I would say 10deg pitch and 4400-4600 rpm, both cases at 3000' altitude, 11mph.
The lower pitch props, especially those with higher cup, can get you up to speed when you're running heavily weighted/10deg pitch/higher altitude or any combination of the three. I've experienced this first hand on two different boats and via multiple different propellers. I called ACME and told them how my Mojo was setup and they got back and said the ACME 3407, (15.5x13x0.150") would be the best. So far that has proven true.
I would agree that if SC is advertising, "surf prop", they could assume that you are going to do a mix of surfing/wakeboarding, and in that case 15.5x15 is decent and covers all their bases. However, if you are only surfing and you fall into one or more of the, heavily weighted/10deg pitch/higher altitude categories, then you'll need lower pitch/higher cup. How much depends on how much of each of the attributes listed and, in my opinion, is part of learning how to "dial in" your boat. 
I have never tested or been on a boat that does reverse rotation so I can't speak to that.